Sci-Fi Short Film: How Is This The World - DUST
video description
As for the ending - it was very powerful. but it felt somewhat incomplete.
The Moms avatar. the mother as she called herself in the gym. I thought she was there to be a companion & guide To help the Mom in her mission Why then, would she sing this powerful song that encourages the Mom to leave him alone As per the last lines of the song. The mother is literally doing the opposite of what she said she would do.
Then theres the menacing glance by the female companion her son is in love with. the one over his shoulder. I thought she was neither good or bad
Then, just when I thought there would be some kind of grand interaction. the peak of the movie. What the whole story has been leading up to, to this point. everything just stops. Its over.
I felt disappointed. Like, the story did a great job of creating a connection between the characters & the watchers. so youre emotionally connected to the story & what happens. So when the story abruptly ended. it was like a gut punch. Everything felt hollow.
Im not sure if Im explaining that correctly. Im just trying to explain how the ending emotionally impacted me.
Overall, amazing job! Everything was perfect! Its just the ending that threw me off. I hope to see more work from you!
Kindest Regards;
Nancy
Date: 2024-04-01
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 34
tamielynne7374
I know I already commented about this short, when I watched it on a compilation video. but I REALLY think you guys should make this into a full length movie! Everyone keeps saying ready player one is similar, and suggesting to others to watch it. But this short, is NOTHING like that movie/book. Not even close! It would be so awesome, to see more of this short! It's one of my favorites. Idk if it's due to the nostalgic feel to it, or what. But it just really makes me feel connected to the characters, the storyline, and leaves me wanting to know more. Like will she ever possibly get her son back I know it's meant to be she realizes he's where he belongs. But it could also be open to interpretation. And I believe this short is one that could be taken farther. I've seen quite a bit of other shorts, made into full length movies. And still he just as awesome.
reply
I know I already commented about this short, when I watched it on a compilation video. but I REALLY think you guys should make this into a full length movie! Everyone keeps saying ready player one is similar, and suggesting to others to watch it. But this short, is NOTHING like that movie/book. Not even close! It would be so awesome, to see more of this short! It's one of my favorites. Idk if it's due to the nostalgic feel to it, or what. But it just really makes me feel connected to the characters, the storyline, and leaves me wanting to know more. Like will she ever possibly get her son back I know it's meant to be she realizes he's where he belongs. But it could also be open to interpretation. And I believe this short is one that could be taken farther. I've seen quite a bit of other shorts, made into full length movies. And still he just as awesome.
reply
b1blancer1
They lose sight of eternity in here. I can understand that. Why would you even want to return to reality if you can live in what, for you, is a perfect world Unfortunately, there are consequences to that. There must be a normally functioning brain to interpret virtual reality, which also means a functioning body. Neglect either one long enough and the consequences are catastrophic. He'll die here when he dies there.
It really opens up a larger philosophical question, though. Our bodies furnish our brains with multiple stimuli which our brains interpret as reality. But if you replace the stimuli from the body with similar stimuli from an artificial source, to the brain it will be an equally legitimate reality. It won't know the difference. So which is the real one How do you even define reality in that case
reply
They lose sight of eternity in here. I can understand that. Why would you even want to return to reality if you can live in what, for you, is a perfect world Unfortunately, there are consequences to that. There must be a normally functioning brain to interpret virtual reality, which also means a functioning body. Neglect either one long enough and the consequences are catastrophic. He'll die here when he dies there.
It really opens up a larger philosophical question, though. Our bodies furnish our brains with multiple stimuli which our brains interpret as reality. But if you replace the stimuli from the body with similar stimuli from an artificial source, to the brain it will be an equally legitimate reality. It won't know the difference. So which is the real one How do you even define reality in that case
reply
rider1956a
absent parents in the 60's was replaced by nonstop TV watching
absent parents in the 70's replaced with ATARI 400/800 and others
absent parents in the 80's replaced with the video arcade / pacman
absent parents in the 90's replaced with the role playing games
absents parents in the 2000's replaced with internet roles
absents parents in the 2010's replaced with gaming nations/tournaments
absents parents in the 2020's replaced with hologram visors
what's next
you lose eternity - as this video so aptly puts it
NOTE: It is tough to NOT be an absent parent - it takes time and desire and a lot of help to learn to not be the child of a child (the hacker with alcohol as his binge)
reply
absent parents in the 60's was replaced by nonstop TV watching
absent parents in the 70's replaced with ATARI 400/800 and others
absent parents in the 80's replaced with the video arcade / pacman
absent parents in the 90's replaced with the role playing games
absents parents in the 2000's replaced with internet roles
absents parents in the 2010's replaced with gaming nations/tournaments
absents parents in the 2020's replaced with hologram visors
what's next
you lose eternity - as this video so aptly puts it
NOTE: It is tough to NOT be an absent parent - it takes time and desire and a lot of help to learn to not be the child of a child (the hacker with alcohol as his binge)
reply
dust
I like this one, (just like with most Dust shorts. There a couple of things that have confused me a bit though. Firstly, that opening scene, where the Mum has the VR visor on & is laughing. I'm not sure how it relates to the story, since she spends most of the time trying to get her son out of that world. Secondly, Raj is a different race to her, so I don't see how he can be her son. Strange casting choice. Overall, cool short though. & that song the end is brilliant! Dungeon by Sadie and the Stark. I'm thinking of buying it in the near future.
reply
I like this one, (just like with most Dust shorts. There a couple of things that have confused me a bit though. Firstly, that opening scene, where the Mum has the VR visor on & is laughing. I'm not sure how it relates to the story, since she spends most of the time trying to get her son out of that world. Secondly, Raj is a different race to her, so I don't see how he can be her son. Strange casting choice. Overall, cool short though. & that song the end is brilliant! Dungeon by Sadie and the Stark. I'm thinking of buying it in the near future.
reply
lucyk2371
This would make a great movie. It is similar to ready player one, however I feel this take on it would have more heart. I love the idea of escaping into this fantasy play world. The aesthetic of this one appeals to me more. You could make it more of a philosophical movie. Why would you want to come out of this world even if it hurts your body in the real world I always wondered in Ready Player One if the reason that they wanted to spend all of their time in the Oasis was the cause of the real world looking so bleak or was it vice versa.
reply
This would make a great movie. It is similar to ready player one, however I feel this take on it would have more heart. I love the idea of escaping into this fantasy play world. The aesthetic of this one appeals to me more. You could make it more of a philosophical movie. Why would you want to come out of this world even if it hurts your body in the real world I always wondered in Ready Player One if the reason that they wanted to spend all of their time in the Oasis was the cause of the real world looking so bleak or was it vice versa.
reply
SynthoidSounds
Awesome story, but the music is what really sent this production over the top, especially that last performance. Of all the productions curated by DUST, and I've seen almost all of them for years, this one stands out in its own category. Everyone fit their part perfectly. A lot of work must have gone into creating this, but it all comes together in its own way. It's a bit unclear if she actually saw her son in there, but she still had quite the experience venturing into that parallel universe virtual world.
reply
Awesome story, but the music is what really sent this production over the top, especially that last performance. Of all the productions curated by DUST, and I've seen almost all of them for years, this one stands out in its own category. Everyone fit their part perfectly. A lot of work must have gone into creating this, but it all comes together in its own way. It's a bit unclear if she actually saw her son in there, but she still had quite the experience venturing into that parallel universe virtual world.
reply
jillw892
I love these videos and I hate to complain that they are so dark. I have my brightness turned up all the way still nothing. I have to turn on all the lights in the house just to see the screen and nobody here likes that so I can't watch these videos in the dark please brighten them up just a tad
Edit: it's just the night time scenes so I have to just wait and watch them when I'm underneath the lamp that's a shame I like to be able to watch them all the time
reply
I love these videos and I hate to complain that they are so dark. I have my brightness turned up all the way still nothing. I have to turn on all the lights in the house just to see the screen and nobody here likes that so I can't watch these videos in the dark please brighten them up just a tad
Edit: it's just the night time scenes so I have to just wait and watch them when I'm underneath the lamp that's a shame I like to be able to watch them all the time
reply
b1blancer1
It really opens up a larger philosophical question. Our bodies furnish our brains with multiple stimuli which our brains interpret as reality. But if you replace the stimuli from the body with similar stimuli from an artificial source, to the brain it will be an equally legitimate reality. It won't know the difference. So which is the real one How do you even define reality
reply
It really opens up a larger philosophical question. Our bodies furnish our brains with multiple stimuli which our brains interpret as reality. But if you replace the stimuli from the body with similar stimuli from an artificial source, to the brain it will be an equally legitimate reality. It won't know the difference. So which is the real one How do you even define reality
reply
LuckyBadger
All a mother really wants, is to know that her child is happy and loved. When they grow up and move away, we have to be content with our memories and let them go on their own way. The heartbreak of parenting is that you teach your kids to be independent and make their own choices - and then they do.
reply
All a mother really wants, is to know that her child is happy and loved. When they grow up and move away, we have to be content with our memories and let them go on their own way. The heartbreak of parenting is that you teach your kids to be independent and make their own choices - and then they do.
reply
karinriver9502
The most human handling of the subjects it touches, that I've ever witnessed. Oh how I felt the music in my body. And I knew what the mother knew, a moment before she discovered it herself. So many beautiful tears, even now. Thank you to all those who created this lovely and insightful gift
reply
The most human handling of the subjects it touches, that I've ever witnessed. Oh how I felt the music in my body. And I knew what the mother knew, a moment before she discovered it herself. So many beautiful tears, even now. Thank you to all those who created this lovely and insightful gift
reply
annschrimsher5183
It is amazing how talented you guys are. That was so good! So, didn't the Mom's AI friend tell her that the younger AI, the son's girlfriend, was not supposed to be there Has the son's AI girlfriend reached consciousness and is keeping him there She didn't look very friendly.
reply
It is amazing how talented you guys are. That was so good! So, didn't the Mom's AI friend tell her that the younger AI, the son's girlfriend, was not supposed to be there Has the son's AI girlfriend reached consciousness and is keeping him there She didn't look very friendly.
reply
catsinq5726
I've watched a lot of these and most of them seem like student projects to demonstrate programming and artistic ability. This film had an amazing story and concept that could be a feature length film. Really strong work. Thanks and good luck with a career in film and the arts!
reply
I've watched a lot of these and most of them seem like student projects to demonstrate programming and artistic ability. This film had an amazing story and concept that could be a feature length film. Really strong work. Thanks and good luck with a career in film and the arts!
reply
subhamburnwal9127
I hate this future, and while people will definitely get addicted, especially since less and less work will be required be humans and they will resort to living it all.
OR
We could actually return to the real greens and not the VR.
I hate this future.
reply
I hate this future, and while people will definitely get addicted, especially since less and less work will be required be humans and they will resort to living it all.
OR
We could actually return to the real greens and not the VR.
I hate this future.
reply
marksimmons1193
The music reminded me of an old movie called Twin Peaks Fire Walk with Me. There's a bar scene in the middle of the movie and a girl singing this sad haunting song mimicking Laura Palmers emotions at the time. Eerie and beautiful at the same time. Nice short
reply
The music reminded me of an old movie called Twin Peaks Fire Walk with Me. There's a bar scene in the middle of the movie and a girl singing this sad haunting song mimicking Laura Palmers emotions at the time. Eerie and beautiful at the same time. Nice short
reply
Cosmosisification
Incredible. One time at a campfire I asked everyone if they were offered the chance to be put into a Matrix world permanently, if they'd take it. Most of them said no, but I genuinely think seeing this video would make them at least reconsider the question.
reply
Incredible. One time at a campfire I asked everyone if they were offered the chance to be put into a Matrix world permanently, if they'd take it. Most of them said no, but I genuinely think seeing this video would make them at least reconsider the question.
reply
rem145
This type of situation is probably only 10 years or so away for real. I’ve had a very disappointing personal life but it is a bit better than 2 years ago. Still, something like this could make social media’s impact to society look like the tip of the iceberg
reply
This type of situation is probably only 10 years or so away for real. I’ve had a very disappointing personal life but it is a bit better than 2 years ago. Still, something like this could make social media’s impact to society look like the tip of the iceberg
reply
andyforshaw4239
I wanted to like it but waaaaaaaaaaay too much pointless smoking. Did nothing for character development or atmosphere. There was plenty for the actors to do besides smoking. Loved the music and I skipped to the end just to see how it ended. Decent story.
reply
I wanted to like it but waaaaaaaaaaay too much pointless smoking. Did nothing for character development or atmosphere. There was plenty for the actors to do besides smoking. Loved the music and I skipped to the end just to see how it ended. Decent story.
reply
berjo77
This beats out monsters, vampires, child abduction for a fear level of 10. 0. With four daughters, I can imagine the terror I’d feel knowing my child was trapped by the likes of this kind of tech. Very provocative, well done.
reply
This beats out monsters, vampires, child abduction for a fear level of 10. 0. With four daughters, I can imagine the terror I’d feel knowing my child was trapped by the likes of this kind of tech. Very provocative, well done.
reply
batterbury4477
WOW really great on all levels - world building, acting, editing is just amazing - and the music use and music editing terrific. And big shout out to production design team -Yes would be excellent series.
reply
WOW really great on all levels - world building, acting, editing is just amazing - and the music use and music editing terrific. And big shout out to production design team -Yes would be excellent series.
reply
eight7934
i really like dust videos but why is their never a part 2, 3. 4 etc it gets you into the story and its over and never to be seen or worked on again makes me just want to unsub and never look at dust again.
reply
i really like dust videos but why is their never a part 2, 3. 4 etc it gets you into the story and its over and never to be seen or worked on again makes me just want to unsub and never look at dust again.
reply
Me-th3gj
I'd watch a full movie of this. I like it. I'd change the wig on the guide though. Looks kind of plain on her. I'd give her a stylish, more elegant up-do that maybe sparkles in purple or teal.
reply
I'd watch a full movie of this. I like it. I'd change the wig on the guide though. Looks kind of plain on her. I'd give her a stylish, more elegant up-do that maybe sparkles in purple or teal.
reply
Sonofspam64
I love the music. I don't love that there was no resolution to the story.
But then again, this being DUST and all, they probably demanded a sad ending so no ending was included.
reply
I love the music. I don't love that there was no resolution to the story.
But then again, this being DUST and all, they probably demanded a sad ending so no ending was included.
reply
AprilJMoon
That would be one way to rid the world of people. The last of humankind ending life in a paradise cyberspace, with no real life procreation and child rearing
reply
That would be one way to rid the world of people. The last of humankind ending life in a paradise cyberspace, with no real life procreation and child rearing
reply
Rayq007
Because life is like a prison where we mostly feel the pressure's of life than we feel the freedom to do as we please. We may in fact already living it.
reply
Because life is like a prison where we mostly feel the pressure's of life than we feel the freedom to do as we please. We may in fact already living it.
reply
brucemonkhouse6698
Congratulations to you Sadie and your colleagues. brilliant concept and frighteningly close to what the future could very well look like.
reply
Congratulations to you Sadie and your colleagues. brilliant concept and frighteningly close to what the future could very well look like.
reply
jeffthomas5291
Ever notice most crap now has a white girl & a black guy Me and Mohamed ( Mr. Clay )
Don't abide with interracial couples.
reply
Ever notice most crap now has a white girl & a black guy Me and Mohamed ( Mr. Clay )
Don't abide with interracial couples.
reply
Stonezster
Good Title. How is this the world when every single TV Show has to have a black guy and a white girl in love. What nonsense.
reply
Good Title. How is this the world when every single TV Show has to have a black guy and a white girl in love. What nonsense.
reply
dennispyle4323
The thirsty dust concordingly breathe because chick expectedly nod unlike a guiltless propane. soft, maniacal narcissus
reply
The thirsty dust concordingly breathe because chick expectedly nod unlike a guiltless propane. soft, maniacal narcissus
reply
lindabishop8738
Sadie you are so rockin. I watch this every day. It is haunting and beautiful. Brilliant. Sad. Way above most vids.
reply
Sadie you are so rockin. I watch this every day. It is haunting and beautiful. Brilliant. Sad. Way above most vids.
reply
Random-rt5ec
I'm an old guy spent my childhood swimming in cranberry bog ditches laced with DDT in the 1960's - VR looks much safer
reply
I'm an old guy spent my childhood swimming in cranberry bog ditches laced with DDT in the 1960's - VR looks much safer
reply
patrickdurham8393
Where's the end I know it's considered chic to end in a pile of shit but it doesn't sell movies.
reply
Where's the end I know it's considered chic to end in a pile of shit but it doesn't sell movies.
reply
DarionDAnjou
was her son playing in the avatar of that white girl at the end the one she makes eye contact with
reply
was her son playing in the avatar of that white girl at the end the one she makes eye contact with
reply
carycoller3140
Raj ain't about to give up his white computer program girlfriend. Not gonna happen. You go boy.
reply
Raj ain't about to give up his white computer program girlfriend. Not gonna happen. You go boy.
reply
renekingfisher9065
Does Raj hear his mom holler at him when hes in the gym He turns around as if he heard her.
reply
Does Raj hear his mom holler at him when hes in the gym He turns around as if he heard her.
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
