Top 10 Saddest How I Met Your Mother Moments
video description
Date: 2023-11-20
Related videos
Comments and reviews: 30
Rocky2418
I certainly wouldn't expect it to be number 1 objectively speaking, but man, the scene with Barney and his father was the most memorable and hard-hitting to me - I always tear up when I see Barney's deep pain as he says why couldn't you have been that for me! I suppose because I cared about someone when growing up who had a different but similar experience with one of her parents. Just as Barney's whole life and personality was deeply affected by the actions of not having a dependable father growing up, only to see that he got his life together after the damage was done to him, so too was her life screwed up (as mine as well, to be honest, only for her parent to get her life together after the damage caused by those critical 15 years was done.
Anyway, that's always an emotional one for me to watch, and his delivery of that line was absolutely perfect.
reply
I certainly wouldn't expect it to be number 1 objectively speaking, but man, the scene with Barney and his father was the most memorable and hard-hitting to me - I always tear up when I see Barney's deep pain as he says why couldn't you have been that for me! I suppose because I cared about someone when growing up who had a different but similar experience with one of her parents. Just as Barney's whole life and personality was deeply affected by the actions of not having a dependable father growing up, only to see that he got his life together after the damage was done to him, so too was her life screwed up (as mine as well, to be honest, only for her parent to get her life together after the damage caused by those critical 15 years was done.
Anyway, that's always an emotional one for me to watch, and his delivery of that line was absolutely perfect.
reply
Fooz
I feel like Tracys death should be the first, I mean that I love the gang except Lilly and Barney but when Tracy first appeared on the screen, I loved her more than I loved the gang itself, the ending is a main reason why my love for HIMYM got less, even when I found out it wasnt on Netflix anymore it didnt make me upset, Ted found his soulmate and got married, why do they get him and Robin together by force? Tracy was the only one that Ted never thought of Robin while dating her which shows how much he loved her and they didnt even show a scene of the mothers funeral and probably the gang trying to make Ted feel better, the mother deserved so much way BETTER
reply
I feel like Tracys death should be the first, I mean that I love the gang except Lilly and Barney but when Tracy first appeared on the screen, I loved her more than I loved the gang itself, the ending is a main reason why my love for HIMYM got less, even when I found out it wasnt on Netflix anymore it didnt make me upset, Ted found his soulmate and got married, why do they get him and Robin together by force? Tracy was the only one that Ted never thought of Robin while dating her which shows how much he loved her and they didnt even show a scene of the mothers funeral and probably the gang trying to make Ted feel better, the mother deserved so much way BETTER
reply
Stefana
idkw, but another of the saddest moments for me is when Ted is talking with Robin at the beach before she gets married, then we realize she wasn't there and he was again just imagining talking to her, all alone, then she starts to drift away while the night is ending because he has to let her go and say goodbye to her forever
(even when we know how the series ends that part gets me hard, even more than many of these moments)
_still there's nothing more devastating like the #1, for absolutely sure_
reply
idkw, but another of the saddest moments for me is when Ted is talking with Robin at the beach before she gets married, then we realize she wasn't there and he was again just imagining talking to her, all alone, then she starts to drift away while the night is ending because he has to let her go and say goodbye to her forever
(even when we know how the series ends that part gets me hard, even more than many of these moments)
_still there's nothing more devastating like the #1, for absolutely sure_
reply
mandolo
4: 25 a long and difficult path to a marriage that lasted what, two episodes? Yes I'm still mad about that.
Also Robin's not having kids does not belong that high up imo. Yes it's an emotional moment but it gets dampened by the fact that she didn't want kids in the first place. Tracy talking to Max belongs much higher up in Contrast imo.
Marshall's sadness is authentic because they did this scene in one take without telling Jason Segel what Lily would say to Marshall.
reply
4: 25 a long and difficult path to a marriage that lasted what, two episodes? Yes I'm still mad about that.
Also Robin's not having kids does not belong that high up imo. Yes it's an emotional moment but it gets dampened by the fact that she didn't want kids in the first place. Tracy talking to Max belongs much higher up in Contrast imo.
Marshall's sadness is authentic because they did this scene in one take without telling Jason Segel what Lily would say to Marshall.
reply
Ajay
When Robin is feeling low, Ted is there to cheer her up
When Lily is feeling low, Marshall or Ted is there to cheer her up
When Barney is feeling low, Lily is there to cheer him up
When Marshall is feeling low, Lily or Ted is there to cheer him up
When Ted is feeling low, he is all alone
I hated Ted in first season, I thought he was desperate, but as the series progress he became my most favourite character, his flaw is what makes him relatable.
reply
When Robin is feeling low, Ted is there to cheer her up
When Lily is feeling low, Marshall or Ted is there to cheer her up
When Barney is feeling low, Lily is there to cheer him up
When Marshall is feeling low, Lily or Ted is there to cheer him up
When Ted is feeling low, he is all alone
I hated Ted in first season, I thought he was desperate, but as the series progress he became my most favourite character, his flaw is what makes him relatable.
reply
Connor
the day i watched the episode of marshall's father's death i had fought with my own father the previous day and with my anger and everything i wished he never existed whatsoever after watching it i realized i do not want him 6 feet buried under i want him to be with me all the time i cannot imagine a life without him and i am glad and forever will be glad that he is my father he will never be able to read this since he doesnt know english but i love you dad
reply
the day i watched the episode of marshall's father's death i had fought with my own father the previous day and with my anger and everything i wished he never existed whatsoever after watching it i realized i do not want him 6 feet buried under i want him to be with me all the time i cannot imagine a life without him and i am glad and forever will be glad that he is my father he will never be able to read this since he doesnt know english but i love you dad
reply
ICohen
I know this has nothing to do with the video. But Robin became my least favourite character. She has that attitude of wanting something she can't have. In Last forever pt1 she said Ted was the guy she should have ended up with. And Ted was happy with Tracy. Her screaming at Patrice and trying to sabotage Barney and Nora's relationship is not a good look
reply
I know this has nothing to do with the video. But Robin became my least favourite character. She has that attitude of wanting something she can't have. In Last forever pt1 she said Ted was the guy she should have ended up with. And Ted was happy with Tracy. Her screaming at Patrice and trying to sabotage Barney and Nora's relationship is not a good look
reply
Oliver
While I unequivocally agree with the list, they missed to include any honourable mentions particularly the scene where Marshall has to confront Lily about taking the job as a judge and having a bitter argument and eventually realising what a douchebag He and in the end realising Lily was pregnant with Daisy through Ted's amazing detective work
reply
While I unequivocally agree with the list, they missed to include any honourable mentions particularly the scene where Marshall has to confront Lily about taking the job as a judge and having a bitter argument and eventually realising what a douchebag He and in the end realising Lily was pregnant with Daisy through Ted's amazing detective work
reply
cardwitch
Am I the only one who got fed up with the whole Ted/Robin thing? It made that abrupt ending with Tracy's death and Barney divorcing Robin all the more irritating to me. Hence why I always switch off the last episode early -- seeing Ted/Robin reunite doesn't satisfy me, it makes me want to lob things at the screen.
reply
Am I the only one who got fed up with the whole Ted/Robin thing? It made that abrupt ending with Tracy's death and Barney divorcing Robin all the more irritating to me. Hence why I always switch off the last episode early -- seeing Ted/Robin reunite doesn't satisfy me, it makes me want to lob things at the screen.
reply
Kimmie
Killing the mother of the show is not right and i got something to say that about that when Ted first started talking to the mother and he wants 45 days with her and just let her be and the tv network people needs to put her on the show like for 3 more seasons and seeing the mother in the hospital bed breaks heart
reply
Killing the mother of the show is not right and i got something to say that about that when Ted first started talking to the mother and he wants 45 days with her and just let her be and the tv network people needs to put her on the show like for 3 more seasons and seeing the mother in the hospital bed breaks heart
reply
Noush
I like that Marvin's death was no. 1. I was expecting it to be Tracy's as she is the main character's future wife and all. but it makes sense that it's Marvin bcz we've knows him longer throughout the show and we've also made a special bond with him. like it's not only fr 1 season we've heard about him.
reply
I like that Marvin's death was no. 1. I was expecting it to be Tracy's as she is the main character's future wife and all. but it makes sense that it's Marvin bcz we've knows him longer throughout the show and we've also made a special bond with him. like it's not only fr 1 season we've heard about him.
reply
BubbabaeRrr
What makes Marshall's Dad's death hard for me because That my Uncle who is like a father me Died about The same time his dad died And my Uncle was always there for me Because my father was never There for me And I love my Uncle so much Thank you Uncle Mike I love you
reply
What makes Marshall's Dad's death hard for me because That my Uncle who is like a father me Died about The same time his dad died And my Uncle was always there for me Because my father was never There for me And I love my Uncle so much Thank you Uncle Mike I love you
reply
Michael
On September 19th of this year i received a phone call from my grandfather. Informing me that that morning my dad had suffered stroke #7 that sadly did him in it was a worse situation for me due to the fact i was at work at the time.
R. i. p DAD. 1968 - 2021
reply
On September 19th of this year i received a phone call from my grandfather. Informing me that that morning my dad had suffered stroke #7 that sadly did him in it was a worse situation for me due to the fact i was at work at the time.
R. i. p DAD. 1968 - 2021
reply
Kitty
My mom has said the same things lily said here at 3: 30. We've had conversations and still to this day she says them which sucks because shes the only parent we have but at the same time she stays. She is the one who stayed.
reply
My mom has said the same things lily said here at 3: 30. We've had conversations and still to this day she says them which sucks because shes the only parent we have but at the same time she stays. She is the one who stayed.
reply
Nick
Marshall finding out his dad passed away is one of the saddest moments in tv history because its so real and genuine.
Jason Segel had no idea Marshalls dad was going to die and he was so saddened and shocked.
reply
Marshall finding out his dad passed away is one of the saddest moments in tv history because its so real and genuine.
Jason Segel had no idea Marshalls dad was going to die and he was so saddened and shocked.
reply
Amanda
Rewatching the series this year. && when Marshals dad died, it hit me so much harder this time because my dad died in May of this year of a freak heart attack too. I know the pain hes feeling in that moment.
reply
Rewatching the series this year. && when Marshals dad died, it hit me so much harder this time because my dad died in May of this year of a freak heart attack too. I know the pain hes feeling in that moment.
reply
Stefana
when i saw the time travelers episode where ted is alone at the bar and goes to tracy's apartment to get the extra 45 days back and starts crying, i remember thinking. ohhh man THEY'RE GOING TO KILL HER
reply
when i saw the time travelers episode where ted is alone at the bar and goes to tracy's apartment to get the extra 45 days back and starts crying, i remember thinking. ohhh man THEY'RE GOING TO KILL HER
reply
Liebe
Ted was always alone, but he never let's Robin being sad alone. He was that guy who always secretly loving and helping Robin, the secret admirer, unsung hero, and that was very sad, throughout the series
reply
Ted was always alone, but he never let's Robin being sad alone. He was that guy who always secretly loving and helping Robin, the secret admirer, unsung hero, and that was very sad, throughout the series
reply
Rob
If I was Ted, I could see eventually hating Robin. As she picked the most BS person. I would also break up with Barney as best friends don't date their best friends ex. (unless maybe best friend dies)
reply
If I was Ted, I could see eventually hating Robin. As she picked the most BS person. I would also break up with Barney as best friends don't date their best friends ex. (unless maybe best friend dies)
reply
Ernesto
The season finale of episode 9 seriously has to be saddest and most satisfying way to end such an amazing comedy.
It even reminded me of my amazing ex girlfriend whom I just broke up with
reply
The season finale of episode 9 seriously has to be saddest and most satisfying way to end such an amazing comedy.
It even reminded me of my amazing ex girlfriend whom I just broke up with
reply
Tatum
The entirety of marshalls dads funeral episode i was sobbing so hard, it hit even harder for me because i was watching it for the first time on the 8 year anniversary of my grandpas death: /
reply
The entirety of marshalls dads funeral episode i was sobbing so hard, it hit even harder for me because i was watching it for the first time on the 8 year anniversary of my grandpas death: /
reply
Berke
I cried in the top 2 entry. Robin telling story to her never existed kids hit me hard but the marshall saying I'm not ready for this makes me lose all my body water by tears
reply
I cried in the top 2 entry. Robin telling story to her never existed kids hit me hard but the marshall saying I'm not ready for this makes me lose all my body water by tears
reply
cl4ymore123
for me the most emotional moment was the episode the last page of the playbook that hit me so damn hard. i didnt cry for years for any movie or show. but this did it
reply
for me the most emotional moment was the episode the last page of the playbook that hit me so damn hard. i didnt cry for years for any movie or show. but this did it
reply
DreamgirlBlue
Marshall beening told that his father passed STILL makes sob uncontrollably like it was the first time I was experiencing that with him
Love you big fudge
reply
Marshall beening told that his father passed STILL makes sob uncontrollably like it was the first time I was experiencing that with him
Love you big fudge
reply
Uffe
Tracys death and in general everything sad with her and Marshalls dads death and everything sad with him just hits the feels differently damn what a show
reply
Tracys death and in general everything sad with her and Marshalls dads death and everything sad with him just hits the feels differently damn what a show
reply
Ralia
For me the saddest part is when Tracy says to Ted What mother would miss her daughter's wedding when you rewatching series, it hits so hard
reply
For me the saddest part is when Tracy says to Ted What mother would miss her daughter's wedding when you rewatching series, it hits so hard
reply
Jason
It really was a great series (in spite of the ending. The reason these moments were so sad is that we were so invested in the characters.
reply
It really was a great series (in spite of the ending. The reason these moments were so sad is that we were so invested in the characters.
reply
JS138
Barney talking to his dad was the scene that really got me. My dad is amazing and I try to be amazing for my kids too. That scene hits
reply
Barney talking to his dad was the scene that really got me. My dad is amazing and I try to be amazing for my kids too. That scene hits
reply
Station
marshall saying im not ready for this is so real to me. It makes me truly appreciate my dad. Im forever grateful for what I have.
reply
marshall saying im not ready for this is so real to me. It makes me truly appreciate my dad. Im forever grateful for what I have.
reply
Gallowglass
It all works out. Robin can't have babies, Tracy had a second chance at love, and then Ted and aunt Robin get together. :D
reply
It all works out. Robin can't have babies, Tracy had a second chance at love, and then Ted and aunt Robin get together. :D
reply
Add a review, comment
Other channel videos
